A Utah-based lawyer has been sanctioned by the state’s Court of Appeals after he filed a legal brief containing citations to a nonexistent court case generated by artificial intelligence.

According to court documents reported by ABC4, the Court of Appeals found that attorney Richard Bednar submitted a petition that included “fabricated legal authority” obtained from ChatGPT. The filing referenced a case titled Royer v Nelson—a citation that, upon review, did not exist in any known legal database.

In its ruling, the court emphasized the evolving role of AI in legal research but underscored that it does not exempt lawyers from their professional obligations.

“We agree that the use of AI in the preparation of pleadings is a legal research tool that will continue to evolve with advances in technology,” the Utah Court of Appeals said in its statement. “However, we emphasize that every attorney has an ongoing duty to review and ensure the accuracy of their court filings.”

“In the present case, petitioner’s counsel fell short of their gatekeeping responsibilities as members of the Utah State Bar when they submitted a petition that contained fake precedent generated by ChatGPT,” it added.

The brief, jointly filed by Bednar and fellow Utah attorney Douglas Durbano, was submitted as part of a “timely petition for interlocutory appeal”. However, it was later revealed that Durbano had not been involved in preparing the document. According to the filing, the petition was authored by a law clerk—described as an “unlicensed law clerk” and law school graduate—who was subsequently terminated from the firm.

“It appears that at least some portions of the petition may be AI-generated, including citations and even quotations to at least one case that does not appear to exist in any legal database (and could only be found in ChatGPT),” the respondent’s counsel wrote, as cited by ABC4.

During a hearing in April, Bednar acknowledged the errors, accepted responsibility, and apologized for the incident. He also offered to pay any legal fees resulting from the matter as part of an effort to “make amends”.

As part of the court’s sanctions, Bednar was ordered to:

  • Pay the respondent’s legal fees associated with the petition and hearing,
  • Refund fees to his client for time spent preparing the flawed filing,
  • And donate $1,000 to the Utah-based nonprofit legal aid group And Justice for All.

The case adds to growing scrutiny over the unvetted use of generative AI tools in legal proceedings. It also echoes a similar controversy last year when two New York lawyers were sanctioned for filing a brief with fictitious citations also sourced from ChatGPT.

Follow Our WhatsApp Channel ______________________________________________________________________________________________________

[A MUST HAVE] Evidence Act Demystified With Recent And Contemporary Cases And Materials

“Evidence Act: Complete Annotation” by renowned legal experts Sanni & Etti.

Available now for NGN 40,000 at ASC Publications, 10, Boyle Street, Onikan, Lagos. Beside High Court, TBS. Email publications@ayindesanni.com or WhatsApp +2347056667384. Purchase Link: https://paystack.com/buy/evidence-act-complete-annotation

______________________________________________________________________ “Enhance Legal Practice With Authoritative Reports” — Alexander Payne Offers Comprehensive Law Reports, Spanning Over A Century Of Nigerian Jurisprudence

Interested buyers are encouraged to place their orders and enquiries via: 0704 444 4777, 0704 444 4999, 0818 199 9888 Website: www.alexandernigeria.com

______________________________________________________________________ Groundbreaking Guide For Lawyers: Adigwe Publishes ‘Artificial Intelligence For Lawyers’ With Free Research eBook The book also examines Nigeria's legal ecosystem, focusing on the LPELR and NBA AI Guidelines. As a bonus, every purchase comes with a FREE eBook titled: How to Use the AI Features in LegalPedia and LawPavilion. Ohio Books Ltd praises the publication, stating: "....this is the only Nigerian book I know of on the topic." How to Order: 📞 Call, Text, or WhatsApp: 08034917063 | 07055285878 📧 Email: benadigwe1@gmail.com 🌎 Website: www.benadigwe.com Ebook Version: Access it directly online at https://selar.com/prv626 Authored by Ben Ijeoma Adigwe Esq., ACIarb (UK), LL.M, Dip. in Artificial Intelligence, Director at the Delta State Ministry of Justice, Asaba, Nigeria. ______________________________________________________________________