A young Nigerian lawyer, Ukomah Chukwuemeka Eze Maxwell, has raised concerns on X over what he described as conflicting Supreme Court judgments delivered within weeks of each other, igniting discussions among legal practitioners.

In a post shared on Thursday, Maxwell highlighted two Supreme Court cases with divergent rulings regarding the competency of originating processes signed by legal practitioners.

The first case, Menakaya v. Ezim (2025), delivered on August 25, 2025, involved an originating process signed by J.H.C. Okolo SAN & Co. The Supreme Court, in its judgment, declared that both the originating process and ancillary documents were incompetent, thereby depriving the trial court, the Court of Appeal, and the Supreme Court of jurisdiction to hear the matter. The Court ultimately allowed the appeal and set aside the lower court’s decision in Appeal No. CA/E/131/2004 delivered on March 29, 2019.

Maxwell noted, “By the decision of this court in Okafor & Ors. v. Nweke & Ors., both the originating process which is the bedrock of the suit—and other ancillary processes filed by J.H.C. Okolo SAN & Co. are incompetent. This robbed the trial court of jurisdiction to entertain the suit.”

In contrast, the second case, Olowe v. Aluko (2025), delivered on August 11, 2025, addressed a similar procedural issue. In this matter, the writ of summons was signed by Akin Olujimi, Esq., while the accompanying statement of claim bore signatures of Akeredolu and Olujimi, all duly enrolled legal practitioners. The Supreme Court held that the documents were competent, emphasizing that the endorsement of qualified practitioners satisfied statutory requirements under the Legal Practitioners Act.

“The names of the signatories are clearly identifiable as belonging to persons duly qualified and entitled to practice law under the Legal Practitioners Act. The statement of claim as filed was competent, and the trial court properly received and acted on the evidence,” the judgment stated.

Maxwell drew attention to the fact that one of the law firms involved in Menakaya v. Ezim belongs to a former Attorney General of the Federation, highlighting the high-profile nature of the dispute.

The post prompted reactions from several legal professionals. Lawyer Ndubuisi Ukpai (@UkpaiNdubuisi1) commented, “When Olowe v Aluko first came out, we had a heated argument about it in the office. Then came Menakaya v Ezim. Thank you for drawing it out again, Counsel.”

Meanwhile, Chidi Odinkalu, former Chairman of the National Human Rights Commission (@ChidiOdinkalu), retweeted Maxwell’s post, noting the apparent inconsistency: “One issue, 2 different cases, 2 different judgments, 2 weeks apart, 2 contradictory outcomes. #GoFigure!”

______________________________________________________________________ Explore Nigeria’s Constitutional System — 17 Chapters, 924 Pages Of Insight By Prof. Hagler Sunny Okorie
“Constitutional Law and Constitutionalism in Nigeria” By Prof. Hagler Sunny Okorie
Call to Order Your Copy: 📞 0803 766 7945 | 0802 863 6615 | 0803 225 3813 ✉️ haglersoco@gmail.com 🏢 Winners Chambers, 135 Ehi Road, Aba, Abia State ______________________________________________________________________ Your Guide To Nigeria’s Competition Law — DOA Handbook (Volumes 1 & 2) Released At ₦20,000
DOA Handbook on Nigerian Competition Law
Available for purchase at ₦20,000 Per copy through LawPavilion’s trusted platform. Search for The DOA Handbook on Nigerian Competition Law or use the direct link: Click here. Unlock the complexities of Nigeria’s Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Act (FCCPA) with the DOA Handbook on Nigerian Competition Law, Volumes 1 & 2. ______________________________________________________________________ Alexander Payne Co. Law Reports

Contact & Orders 📞 0704 444 4777 | 0704 444 4999 | 0818 199 9888 🌐 www.alexandernigeria.com

______________________________________________________________________ [Now Available] -- From Crime Scene To Courtroom: An Authoritative Legal Handbook On Police Investigations In this authoritative work, Basil Momodu Esq., titled Police Investigations in Nigeria Through the Cases 📖 Available now Call 07051822705 or any of the recommended independent booksellers listed hereunder. ______________________________________________________________________ “History of Rivers State Judiciary: A Compendium of Personalities on the Bench.” Authored by Ampim Gogo Blankson, Esq., Deputy Director at the Rivers State Ministry of Justice, in collaboration with the Rivers State Judiciary 💰 Cover Price: ₦20,000.00 (Twenty Thousand Naira) Bukky Law Books, Rivers State High Court Complex, Moscow Road, Port Harcourt – 📞 08034868754📞 08034729738📞 Enquiries: ______________________________________________________________________ [A MUST HAVE] Evidence Act Demystified With Recent And Contemporary Cases And Materials
“Evidence Act: Complete Annotation” by renowned legal experts Sanni & Etti.
Available now for NGN 40,000 at ASC Publications, 10, Boyle Street, Onikan, Lagos. Beside High Court, TBS. Email publications@ayindesanni.com or WhatsApp +2347056667384. Purchase Link: https://paystack.com/buy/evidence-act-complete-annotation _________________________________________________________________