Ruling in the suit/ CA// ETP/27/2015, Hon. Justice I. G. Mbaba described the ruling of the tribunal as not only misconceived but sad and absurd by rejecting the true certified copy of the INEC document, stating that the accred­ited voters register of Abia North, met the provisions of the Evidence Act in respect to computer gener­ated data. He noted that the accredited vot­ers’ register was duly signed by both the head of ICT and the deputy director, legal department of INEC without any alteration. He stated that the respondents did not contest the veracity but had objected to its being tendered as an evidence be­cause it was a computer generated data. “The ruling of the tribunal has made nonsense of the Evidence Act and has shown their poor under­standing of the Evidence Act that a true certified copy of a document represents the original of that docu­ment and the tribunal was wrong to fish for evidence to reject it when it said that the INEC should have come to prove that the copy was genuine. The respondents should pay N50,000 only as a cost of the Appeal to the appellant”, Justice Mbaba ruled. The counsel to Dr Orji Uzor Kalu, Hippolatius Uzoma Ude said that the crux of the appeal was for the Court of Appeal to set aside the decision of the election petition panel sitting in Umuahia which rejected the list of accred­ited voters register of Abia North from the ICT department of the Independent National Electoral Commission from Abuja on the ground that it does not comply with section 84 (1&2) of the Evi­dence Act 2011. “The Judges of the Court of Ap­peal in its ruling have proved us right and they said that the ruling of the tribunal was misconceived which negated section 84 (1&2), that the document was admissible having been duly certified by the public official who is in custody of the original document and that the public officer does not have to come before the court to tender it. So, the Court of Appeal has exer­cised its powers under section 15 of the Court of Appeal Act of 2014 and admitted on their own the evi­dence rejected by the tribunal and that has given the appellant the edge to argue his matter to refer to that document”, he added.]]>

Top News

Metro News

FAAC allocates N616.19bn to FG, states, LGs for April

The Federation Account Allocation Committee on Tuesday night distributed the sum of N616.19bn from the federation account to the three tiers of government as...

Litigation

Nigerian Parliament

NBA

Commentaries

NASS Leadership: Secret Vs Open Ballotby Michael Jegede

Soon after the 2019 presidential/National Assembly elections, the battle for the seats of presiding officers for the ninth Assembly began in earnest, with elected...

Why The Heat, Can A Man Be R*ped Under Our Nigerian...

Series of arguments abound and this has caused much heat as to whether a man can be raped under our current Nigerian Laws.  A...

Judges

Business News

Business News

Government Policies

Election Tribunal

Law Enforcement Agencies

International News

Jobs

Subscribe ToTheNigeriaLawyer News!