Senior Advocate of Nigeria, Jibrin Okutepa, SAN, has called on the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) to uphold fairness and consistency in enforcing professional ethics, warning that disciplinary proceedings against lawyers must not become instruments for silencing legitimate criticism of judicial decisions while misconduct within the legal profession and the judiciary goes unaddressed.

Okutepa maintained that although no lawyer has the right to insult or personally abuse a judge, the NBA must demonstrate the same commitment to professional discipline when allegations of misconduct involve lawyers holding political offices, judicial officers or members of its own leadership.

The senior advocate made the observations in a statement posted on his X account on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, while reacting to reports that the NBA had initiated disciplinary proceedings against a lawyer before the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee (LPDC) over alleged insulting remarks directed at a judge.

The development follows an earlier report by TheNigeriaLawyer concerning a petition by the NBA President against lawyer Kalu Kalu over remarks relating to a judicial officer.

Although Okutepa did not identify the lawyer involved in his statement, he acknowledged the NBA’s authority to initiate disciplinary complaints against legal practitioners accused of professional misconduct.

“A Nigerian lawyer has been dragged before the LPDC for allegedly using insulting language against a judge,” he stated.

Okutepa explained that he did not intend to become involved in the political arguments surrounding the disciplinary complaint but considered it necessary to address the broader ethical issues affecting the legal profession.

“The NBA has a duty to make complaints,” he said. “The LPDC was established to adjudicate complaints of professional misconduct. There is no doubt about that.”

He stressed that lawyers have a professional responsibility to exercise restraint when commenting on judicial decisions, even where they strongly disagree with a court’s reasoning or conclusion.

“Let me be clear from the beginning: no lawyer should insult a judge. An advocate’s responsibility carries a duty of restraint, even in the face of profound disagreement with a judicial decision,” Okutepa stated.

The senior advocate, however, cautioned that abusive language directed at judicial officers was not the only conduct capable of attracting professional disciplinary proceedings.

He questioned what steps the NBA had taken concerning lawyers involved in politics who, according to him, had publicly acknowledged influencing judicial decisions.

Okutepa asked whether such conduct should not equally attract the attention of the association’s disciplinary mechanisms.

“What has the NBA done about some lawyers in politics who have consistently admitted on national television to influencing judicial decisions? Is that not professional misconduct?” he queried.

He did not identify the lawyers involved or provide details of the alleged admissions.

According to Okutepa, the responsibility to maintain professional ethics should extend beyond lawyers who make offensive statements about judges to other conduct capable of undermining public confidence in the administration of justice.

He maintained that lawyers were entitled to criticise judicial decisions, expose errors in legal reasoning and condemn perceived injustice, provided they did so without resorting to personal abuse.

The senior advocate argued that there was a clear distinction between robust criticism of a judgment and insults directed at the personality of a judicial officer.

He explained that lawyers could challenge judicial reasoning and speak firmly against injustice without compromising the dignity of the legal profession.

“Personal abuse weakens the argument, diminishes the profession and distracts attention from the injustice being challenged,” he stated.

Turning to the responsibilities of judicial officers, Okutepa maintained that judges were equally bound by ethical obligations requiring independence, impartiality and fidelity to the law.

He warned that judicial decisions should not give reasonable grounds for the perception that justice had been influenced by political loyalty, personal interests or external pressure.

“Equally, no judge should deliver a judgment that gives reasonable grounds for the perception that justice has been surrendered to political loyalty, personal interest or outside influence,” he said.

According to him, the judicial oath requires judges to uphold independence, impartiality, integrity and strict adherence to the law, with those principles reflected in both the reasoning and conduct of judicial proceedings.

Okutepa nevertheless clarified that judges could not be held responsible simply because their decisions provoked criticism or anger from disappointed litigants and lawyers.

He acknowledged that a judgment could be unpopular while remaining legally sound and just.

“A judge cannot guarantee that a disappointed litigant or counsel will respond responsibly. An unpopular judgment may be entirely just,” he stated.

He explained that the proper ethical standard was for judges to deliver decisions supported by the law and evidence, reached through fair proceedings and accompanied by reasons capable of withstanding objective scrutiny.

The senior advocate maintained that neither judicial error nor misconduct justified personal abuse by lawyers, just as abusive criticism should not prevent legitimate examination of judicial decisions.

“Judicial error or misconduct does not excuse abuse; neither does abusive criticism erase legitimate questions about a judgment,” Okutepa declared.

He consequently urged the NBA to maintain a balanced approach to professional ethics by defending judicial officers against intimidation and personal attacks while also demanding accountability where credible evidence raised questions about judicial conduct.

“The NBA must hold these scales evenly,” he stated.

Okutepa warned that defending judicial independence should not become a justification for shielding judicial decisions from legitimate criticism.

He equally cautioned that disciplinary proceedings should not be used to discourage legal practitioners from speaking against perceived injustice.

According to him, the NBA’s responsibility to protect the judiciary must exist alongside its duty to preserve the independence and courage of legal practitioners who raise legitimate concerns about the administration of justice.

The senior advocate further challenged the association to demonstrate the ethical standards it demands from its members through its own internal processes.

He maintained that the NBA’s elections, leadership selection procedures, disciplinary mechanisms and general administration must reflect fairness, transparency and respect for professional obligations.

Okutepa argued that an association seeking to enforce integrity among lawyers must first ensure that its internal affairs are conducted in accordance with those principles.

“An association cannot credibly preach integrity while tolerating practices that undermine integrity in the emergence of its own leaders,” he stated.

“Where an association desecrates ethical standards in producing its leadership, it forfeits the moral authority to lecture others on those standards.”

He warned that perceived failures in the NBA’s internal processes could undermine public confidence in its disciplinary interventions and expose the association to accusations of selective enforcement.

However, Okutepa clarified that failures by the association would not absolve individual lawyers of their professional responsibilities.

According to him, lawyers remained bound by ethical obligations regardless of the conduct of the association’s leadership.

He nevertheless maintained that where the NBA failed to demonstrate fairness and integrity in its own affairs, its disciplinary demands could appear selective and vulnerable to accusations of hypocrisy.

The senior advocate did not identify any particular NBA election, officer or disciplinary proceeding as the subject of his criticism.

He urged the association’s leadership to welcome scrutiny, respond to legitimate complaints and correct established wrongs rather than relying on appeals for unity or institutional dignity to avoid accountability.

“Calls for unity cannot substitute for accountability, and appeals to institutional dignity cannot justify concealing misconduct,” he stated.

Okutepa maintained that strengthening public confidence in Nigeria’s justice system required a collective commitment to professional responsibility among lawyers, judicial officers and the leadership of the Bar.

“The profession needs lawyers who speak with courage and restraint, judges who decide with independence and integrity, and an NBA whose conduct gives weight to its words,” he said.

He emphasised that respect for judicial institutions and accountability within those institutions were complementary responsibilities rather than conflicting obligations.

According to him, the NBA would command greater public confidence when it demonstrated consistency in addressing ethical concerns, irrespective of the individuals or institutions involved.

He therefore urged the association to apply the same professional standards to advocates, judicial officers and its own leadership “without fear, favour or partisan calculation.”

Follow Our WhatsApp Channel ______________________________________________________________________________________________________

[A MUST HAVE] Evidence Act Demystified With Recent And Contemporary Cases And Materials

“Evidence Act: Complete Annotation” by renowned legal experts Sanni & Etti.

Available now for NGN 40,000 at ASC Publications, 10, Boyle Street, Onikan, Lagos. Beside High Court, TBS. Email publications@ayindesanni.com or WhatsApp +2347056667384. Purchase Link: https://paystack.com/buy/evidence-act-complete-annotation

______________________________________________________________________ “Enhance Legal Practice With Authoritative Reports” — Alexander Payne Offers Comprehensive Law Reports, Spanning Over A Century Of Nigerian Jurisprudence

Interested buyers are encouraged to place their orders and enquiries via: 0704 444 4777, 0704 444 4999, 0818 199 9888 Website: www.alexandernigeria.com

______________________________________________________________________

“A Comprehensive Guide To Evidence Law” — Releases Second Edition In Three Volumes, Covering 4,051 Cases

  For enquiries and orders, contact: 08035526491 Email: jerryamadisilk@gmail.com Prof. Jerry Amadi’s Evidence Law, Second Edition (2026), contains 3,314 pages in three volumes, covering the Evidence Act 2011, its 2023 amendment, and 4,051 Nigerian and English cases.