A leadership dispute has erupted at The Fountain of Life Church, Lagos, following the announcement by its Board of Trustees that Pastor Jimmy Odukoya has been removed as Senior Pastor over disagreements concerning his appointment, the late founder’s succession instructions and the administration of the church.

However, Odukoya has rejected the decision, insisting that his appointment as Senior Pastor and Chairman of the Board of Trustees remains constitutionally valid and that the individuals seeking his removal lack the authority to take binding decisions on behalf of the church.

The controversy intensified after the trustees announced the appointment of Pastor Rotimi Okpaise to oversee the spiritual and administrative affairs of the church on an interim basis, pending consultations and further processes for establishing a substantive leadership structure.

In a statement dated November 17, 2026, the trustees disclosed that they had resolved at a meeting held on November 16 that Jimmy Odukoya “is no longer recognised as Senior Pastor of The Fountain of Life Church, with immediate effect.”

The statement further declared that he “is required to step down forthwith from the office and all functions of Senior Pastor.”

According to the trustees, the decision followed a review of the church’s constitution, the circumstances surrounding Odukoya’s appointment in September 2023 and recorded instructions allegedly left by his late father and founder of the church, Pastor Taiwo Odukoya, before his death in August 2023.

The trustees maintained that the review raised fundamental questions about the legitimacy of the succession process, particularly whether all relevant information concerning the founder’s wishes had been disclosed before Jimmy was appointed.

They disclosed that a video recording attributed to the late Pastor Taiwo Odukoya identified Pastor Kunle Areogun, rather than Jimmy, as his preferred successor.

The recording, said to have been made in December 2021 at the founder’s request and witnessed by his eldest son, Pastor John Odukoya, contained instructions concerning the future leadership of the church in the event of his death or incapacity.

In the recording, the late founder stated:

“But the reason I’m doing this is to let you know that incase of my demise, which I don’t expect to happen soon, or a situation where I cannot write or talk, please, the next pastor of the church should be Kunle Areogun and to be his immediate assistant, that is in terms of administration, is Jimmy Odukoya, who will be the head of the youth church.”

Pastor Taiwo further explained that the instructions related to an aspect of the church’s constitution that was undergoing review at the time.

“Every other thing remains the same as laid out in the constitution. The reason I am doing this again is this, because that is an aspect of the constitution that we are trying to rework which we haven’t concluded. We will continue to do that but if for any reason I am not able to see that through this is what I intend they should follow,” he stated.

The trustees said the recording was not brought to their attention until late December 2025, approximately four years after it was made and more than two years after the founder’s death.

They alleged that its existence and contents were not disclosed during the deliberations that resulted in Jimmy’s appointment as Senior Pastor in September 2023.

According to the board, Jimmy had informed the trustees and subsequently the congregation that his father had handed over the leadership of the ministry to him.

“Upon enquiry by the Board, Pastor Jimmy Odukoya informed the Board, and subsequently the Church, that our late Senior Pastor had handed the mantle of leadership over to him. The Board placed considerable reliance upon this assurance in its deliberations on the succession,” the statement said.

The trustees maintained that they approved Jimmy’s appointment in good faith, based on the information available to them and their understanding of the church’s constitution.

However, they argued that the subsequent discovery of the recording raised concerns about whether their decision had been reached with full knowledge of the late founder’s expressed intentions.

“Significantly, the individual nominated in that recording was not Pastor Jimmy Odukoya,” the board stated.

It added that the recording was not presented during the original deliberations, thereby depriving the trustees of information that could have influenced their decision.

“The fundamental issue, therefore, is not simply the identity of the person appointed, but whether the Board’s decision was reached on the basis of full, accurate and transparent disclosure of all material information relevant to the succession process,” the trustees explained.

The board maintained that succession in a Christian institution should be guided by transparency, established procedures and respect for the intentions of its founding leadership.

Beyond the succession recording, the trustees accused Jimmy of failing to cooperate adequately with attempts to resolve disagreements concerning the church’s administration and governance.

They disclosed that several months of consultations and reconciliation efforts, including interventions by respected Christian leaders described as “Fathers of the Faith,” had failed to resolve the dispute.

“Regrettably, notwithstanding these interventions, repeated representations and efforts at reconciliation, the substantive concerns raised by the Board remain unresolved. Pastor Jimmy Odukoya has not provided the level of engagement and cooperation necessary to achieve a satisfactory resolution,” the statement alleged.

The trustees also referred to what they described as moral and doctrinal controversies affecting the church’s reputation and unity, although they did not provide specific details of those allegations.

“Having carefully considered the cumulative effects of the unresolved governance concerns, the present moral and doctrinal controversies, and the resulting damage to the reputation and unity of the Church, the Board of Trustees considers that decisive intervention is now imperative,” they stated.

Consequently, the trustees announced Okpaise’s interim appointment while consultations continued on the substantive leadership of the ministry.

However, the statement did not explain why Okpaise was selected for the interim role when the founder’s recording identified Areogun as his preferred successor.

It also did not disclose whether Areogun had been approached or how the late founder’s instructions would be considered alongside the church’s constitutional procedures in determining its future leadership.

Reacting to the announcement in a statement posted on his X account on Tuesday, Jimmy Odukoya rejected the purported removal, arguing that it did not represent a constitutionally valid decision of the church’s Board of Trustees.

He maintained that the individuals behind the announcement had acted outside the governing framework of the church.

According to Jimmy, the announcement “represents the position of certain individuals who have constituted themselves into a group describing itself as ‘Concerned Members of the Board’ and who continue to act outside the constitutional framework governing the Church”.

He alleged that the trustees concerned had previously been formally requested to resign through a communication dated March 14, 2026, following what he described as repeated violations of the church’s constitution and founding principles.

Jimmy maintained that the communication had been delivered to and acknowledged by the affected trustees and that one of them subsequently resigned.

“That communication was duly delivered to and acknowledged by the Trustees concerned, and one of the Trustees subsequently tendered a resignation following that communication,” his statement said.

He further alleged that instead of addressing the constitutional concerns raised against them, the remaining individuals continued taking decisions purportedly on behalf of the church without complying with its governing constitution.

Jimmy insisted that he remained the duly appointed Senior Pastor and Chairman of the Board of Trustees.

His statement maintained that his appointment in September 2023 was unanimously approved by the trustees and that no valid constitutional process had removed him from either position.

“His appointment was unanimously approved by the Board of Trustees in September 2023, and no constitutionally valid decision removing him from either office has been established,” the statement said.

He argued that the church’s constitution remained its supreme governing instrument and that the personal preferences of individuals or groups could not replace its express provisions.

“We remain committed to the founding vision, peace, unity, spiritual mission, and constitutional governance of the Church and reserve the right to take all appropriate lawful steps to protect its integrity,” the statement added.

The disagreement has also extended to control of the church’s official social media platforms.

The trustees alleged that Jimmy, or persons acting on his behalf, had taken control of the church’s social media channels without authorisation and used them to circulate information that the board considered inaccurate and misleading.

“The Board has become aware that, since that announcement, the Church’s official social media channels have been taken over by, or on behalf of, Pastor Jimmy Odukoya without the authorisation of the Board,” the trustees alleged.

They consequently warned members of the congregation, journalists and the public against treating statements published on those platforms as representing the board’s official position.

The trustees maintained that only communications issued and signed on behalf of the board should be regarded as authoritative, adding that steps were being taken to restore authorised control of the platforms.

However, a counterstatement circulated through the church’s official social media account maintained Jimmy’s position that the purported removal was unconstitutional and that the trustees seeking to remove him lacked the authority to act on behalf of the church.

The competing statements have therefore created a dispute not only over the proper interpretation of the late founder’s succession instructions but also over the composition, authority and decision-making powers of the church’s Board of Trustees.

Defending their decision, the trustees insisted that the move against Jimmy was not motivated by personal hostility or an intention to humiliate him.

“The Board emphasises that this decision is not intended as an act of vindictiveness, humiliation or personal condemnation,” the statement said.

“Rather, it is a necessary and proportionate response to circumstances which, if left unaddressed, could inflict lasting damage on the Church and the legacy entrusted to its care.”

The trustees maintained that their overriding responsibility was to protect the church’s founding vision, doctrine, institutional integrity and the spiritual welfare of its congregation.

They appealed to members to remain peaceful and prayerful while efforts continued to address the leadership dispute.

“The Fountain of Life Church is greater than any individual, office or generation of leadership,” the board declared.

It further expressed the hope that the ministry would overcome the crisis and preserve its founding mission.

“The Fountain of Life Church must emerge from this crisis stronger, purified, united and firmly anchored in the Word of God,” the trustees stated.

Follow Our WhatsApp Channel ______________________________________________________________________________________________________

[A MUST HAVE] Evidence Act Demystified With Recent And Contemporary Cases And Materials

“Evidence Act: Complete Annotation” by renowned legal experts Sanni & Etti.

Available now for NGN 40,000 at ASC Publications, 10, Boyle Street, Onikan, Lagos. Beside High Court, TBS. Email publications@ayindesanni.com or WhatsApp +2347056667384. Purchase Link: https://paystack.com/buy/evidence-act-complete-annotation

______________________________________________________________________ “Enhance Legal Practice With Authoritative Reports” — Alexander Payne Offers Comprehensive Law Reports, Spanning Over A Century Of Nigerian Jurisprudence

Interested buyers are encouraged to place their orders and enquiries via: 0704 444 4777, 0704 444 4999, 0818 199 9888 Website: www.alexandernigeria.com

______________________________________________________________________

“A Comprehensive Guide To Evidence Law” — Releases Second Edition In Three Volumes, Covering 4,051 Cases

  For enquiries and orders, contact: 08035526491 Email: jerryamadisilk@gmail.com Prof. Jerry Amadi’s Evidence Law, Second Edition (2026), contains 3,314 pages in three volumes, covering the Evidence Act 2011, its 2023 amendment, and 4,051 Nigerian and English cases.