Former President of the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA), Chief Joseph Bodurin Daudu, SAN, has warned that the establishment of state police in Nigeria will require at least five years to develop a solid, sustainable and effective policing structure, even after the proposed constitutional amendments receive presidential assent.

Daudu maintained that the mere passage of legislation permitting states to establish their own police services would not automatically resolve Nigeria’s security challenges, stressing that the success of the reform would depend on adequate infrastructure, operational capacity, institutional safeguards and effective implementation.

The senior advocate made the observation while delivering his welcome address on behalf of the Rule of Law Development Foundation at the opening of its 8th Annual Criminal Law Review Conference.

The conference, which commenced on Monday, November 16, 2026, and will conclude on Friday, November 20, is being held at the conference hall of the National Open University of Nigeria, with virtual participation from locations across Nigeria and abroad.

Speaking on the proposed decentralisation of policing, Daudu said the Foundation had consistently advocated state police long before the proposal gained widespread political and public acceptance.

According to him, the Foundation’s position on the issue previously sounded like “a lone voice in the wilderness”, but the growing support for state policing had made it necessary to focus on developing a workable structure.

He emphasised that Nigeria must avoid assuming that constitutional amendments would immediately translate into effective policing at the state level.

Daudu explained that although the proposed reform represented an important step towards addressing the country’s security challenges, implementation would require substantial investment, institutional development and cooperation between federal and state authorities.

He maintained that the legislative process was only the beginning of the more demanding task of establishing functional police services across the federation.

The former NBA President traced Nigeria’s policing arrangements to its colonial and constitutional history, explaining that the country’s diverse cultural, linguistic and regional characteristics had influenced the development of its federal structure.

He recalled that Nigeria emerged from colonial arrangements following the European partition of Africa associated with the 1884 conference, with the colony of Lagos and the Northern and Southern Protectorates eventually amalgamated in 1914.

According to him, the constitutional developments of 1946 and 1954 reflected an early recognition that the country’s diversity required a federal system in which governmental powers were shared between the central authority and the federating units.

Daudu explained that Nigeria had experimented with different policing structures, including arrangements involving a single police organisation and systems permitting policing at different levels.

He noted that native authority police organisations continued to exist after independence before changes in the country’s political and security arrangements altered the structure of law enforcement.

The senior advocate further observed that during military rule, several paramilitary institutions acquired policing responsibilities for various reasons, including inadequate legal frameworks, weak institutional structures, corruption and insufficient political will.

According to him, Nigeria’s experience with these arrangements demonstrated the need to reconsider the present centralised policing system.

Daudu maintained that members of the political class and the intelligentsia appeared increasingly convinced that the existing constitutional structure was inadequate to address the country’s security challenges.

He specifically identified Sections 214 and 215 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999, as amended, as provisions governing the present policing structure.

However, he stressed that those constitutional provisions remained applicable because the proposed amendments establishing state police had not yet received presidential assent.

He cautioned against discussing the new policing framework as though it had already become operative law.

According to him, until the proposed amendments come into force, the constitutional position remains that Nigeria has a single police force established for the federation.

Revisiting the Foundation’s earlier position, Daudu recalled a paper in which he argued that “Nigeria is under-policed” and required urgent decentralisation of its security architecture.

He maintained that whether the solution was described as state policing or community policing, the country needed a structure responsive to the peculiar security requirements of its 36 states and the Federal Capital Territory.

The Foundation had consequently recommended amendments to Section 214 of the Constitution to permit state police services, with clearly defined jurisdictions and effective accountability mechanisms.

It also proposed legal provisions supporting community policing networks and local intelligence structures capable of cooperating with federal law enforcement agencies.

Another recommendation was the establishment of a federal oversight institution responsible for promoting uniform operational standards and preventing the abuse of policing powers by state authorities.

Daudu observed that these proposals had now gained substantial legislative and political acceptance, with the constitutional amendment process approaching completion.

He explained that the proposed changes would provide for federal and state police services, including arrangements for the appointment of state police commanders.

The amendments would also address the powers of governors to issue directives, safeguards against abuse, circumstances permitting federal intervention and national minimum policing standards.

However, Daudu expressed concern about the possibility of difficulties arising from separate command structures under the proposed arrangement.

He maintained that the relationship between federal and state policing authorities would require careful attention to avoid operational conflicts.

The senior advocate explained that the proposed Sixth Alteration to the Constitution affected several provisions of the 1999 Constitution.

Among the provisions he identified were Sections 84, 89, 121, 124, 129, 153, 157, 158, 197, 204 and 214.

He said the amendments extended across approximately three pages of constitutional provisions, illustrating the scope of the proposed restructuring.

Daudu nevertheless warned that the passage of the amendments would not, by itself, guarantee improved security or compel every state to establish a comprehensive policing service.

He drew attention to earlier constitutional amendments that expanded the legislative powers of states in areas previously subject to greater federal control.

According to him, the Fifth Alteration to the Constitution enabled states to legislate on electricity and correctional services by placing the relevant matters on the Concurrent Legislative List.

He observed that although the constitutional framework permitted greater state participation in electricity regulation, only a few states, including Abia and Lagos, had taken substantial steps to exercise the powers.

Similarly, he said no state had established its own correctional service despite the constitutional changes permitting state involvement.

Daudu argued that the experience demonstrated the difference between granting states constitutional authority to perform a function and their capacity or willingness to exercise that authority effectively.

He warned that a similar situation could emerge following the introduction of state policing, particularly where state governments lacked adequate funding, infrastructure or institutional preparedness.

According to him, the existence of legislation authorising state police would not necessarily result in an immediate reduction in criminal activities or an automatic improvement in public safety.

He maintained that the country must prepare for a gradual process of establishing the institutions, facilities and operational systems required for effective policing.

Speaking on behalf of the Foundation, Daudu predicted that the proposed state policing system would need at least five years to develop a foundation capable of sustaining effective operations.

He explained that the period would be necessary to establish a solid and irreversible institutional framework and achieve a reasonable degree of operational effectiveness.

The former NBA President identified infrastructure development as one of the principal challenges confronting the proposed reform.

According to him, the 36 states would need to establish police stations and other operational facilities across communities, districts, local government headquarters and state capitals.

He maintained that the scale of the infrastructure required would be enormous and could place substantial demands on the resources of state governments.

Daudu also cautioned against arrangements under which federal and state police services would operate from the same premises, arguing that separate facilities would be necessary for the proposed policing structures.

He further identified the acquisition of communication equipment and related operational technology as another major requirement.

According to him, effective policing would depend on the availability of adequate communication systems capable of supporting coordination, intelligence gathering and timely responses to security threats.

The senior advocate maintained that these practical considerations must form part of the implementation process if state police services are to become effective.

Earlier in his address, Daudu explained that the Rule of Law Development Foundation was established approximately eight years ago and that the Annual Criminal Law Review Conference had become one of its flagship programmes.

He said the conference provided a platform for reviewing developments in Nigeria’s criminal justice system, particularly emerging legal issues affecting criminal investigation, prosecution and adjudication.

According to him, the Foundation also examines post-adjudication processes and the institutions responsible for the administration of criminal justice, including correctional centres and borstals.

The annual review considers the legal framework governing the powers and functions of the Nigeria Police Force, other law enforcement agencies, courts exercising criminal jurisdiction and institutions responsible for correctional services.

Daudu explained that the Foundation also evaluates criminal procedure and sentencing legislation, alongside the effectiveness of correctional institutions.

While acknowledging the difficult conditions under which Nigerian courts discharge their responsibilities, he said the conference would review recent judgments of superior courts, particularly the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal, on criminal law issues arising between 2025 and 2026.

He disclosed that more than 400 delegates were participating in the conference physically and virtually.

According to him, over 100 participants were drawn from federal ministries and services, including the Nigeria Immigration Service, Federal Fire Service, Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps and Nigerian Correctional Service.

He also disclosed that more than 100 participants from the Federal Capital Territory were sponsored by the FCT Minister, with additional delegates drawn from branches of the Nigerian Bar Association.

Daudu acknowledged the participation of the Attorney-General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, the Minister of Interior, representatives of state governors, members of the judiciary, Senior Advocates of Nigeria, members of the NBA and representatives of the media.

He also recognised the Minister of the Federal Capital Territory, who was represented by the General Counsel of the FCT Administration.

The senior advocate thanked the state authorities and other institutions that supported the conference, including a state government that sponsored delegates and the governor of a state hosting one of the satellite venues, who was represented by a senior lawyer.

Outlining the conference programme, Daudu said the second day would examine the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee (LPDC), including questions concerning its disciplinary authority over lawyers and the relationship between professional autonomy and accountability.

The programme would also examine Nigeria’s fiscal policy and tax reforms, particularly the transition from the Federal Inland Revenue Service to the Nigeria Revenue Service.

He explained that the discussions would consider lawyers’ tax obligations and the civil and criminal liabilities that could arise from non-compliance with taxation laws.

In a light-hearted remark, Daudu warned that legal practitioners who had failed to discharge their tax responsibilities might eventually be called upon to account for their obligations.

He therefore encouraged participants to attend the session and familiarise themselves with their responsibilities under the developing tax framework.

On the third day, the conference would examine contemporary developments in the Administration of Criminal Justice system between 2025 and 2026.

Daudu specifically referred to the deaths of certain detainees in Niger State, describing the development as “very unfortunate”.

He said the Foundation had examined a report concerning the incident and intended to discuss measures that could prevent a recurrence.

The afternoon session would focus on digital governance, technology regulation and the circumstances in which criminal liability could arise from the use of modern technologies, particularly social media.

The fourth day would feature judicial updates concerning Nigeria’s criminal justice system between 2025 and 2026.

It would also include a review of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA), which has been in operation for 11 years.

According to Daudu, the session on the ACJA would be chaired by one of the founding fathers of the legislation.

The fifth and final day would focus on human rights and transparency, including a discussion on whether Nigeria required legislation to regulate and control civil society organisations and non-governmental organisations.

Daudu explained that the Foundation’s work also included examining legislative developments from the National Assembly and the 36 State Houses of Assembly, particularly where such laws affected the administration of criminal justice.

He identified the proposed establishment of state police as a major legislative development requiring careful examination because of its implications for law enforcement, constitutional governance and public safety.

The former NBA President reiterated that the growing acceptance of state policing represented an important development in Nigeria’s search for more effective security arrangements.

However, he maintained that the real test would lie in translating constitutional provisions into functioning institutions capable of protecting citizens and maintaining law and order.

He cautioned that the country must not confuse legislative approval with operational readiness, stressing that the establishment of state police services would require sustained institutional development after the constitutional amendments take effect.

According to Daudu, the reform’s long-term success would depend on the capacity of states to establish appropriate infrastructure, acquire essential operational equipment and implement safeguards against abuse.

He maintained that the next stage of the process should therefore focus on building a reliable policing structure rather than assuming that the constitutional amendment alone would resolve Nigeria’s security difficulties.

Daudu concluded his observations on state policing by emphasising that even after the necessary laws come into force, the journey towards establishing an effective and sustainable decentralised policing system would only have begun.

Follow Our WhatsApp Channel ______________________________________________________________________________________________________

[A MUST HAVE] Evidence Act Demystified With Recent And Contemporary Cases And Materials

“Evidence Act: Complete Annotation” by renowned legal experts Sanni & Etti.

Available now for NGN 40,000 at ASC Publications, 10, Boyle Street, Onikan, Lagos. Beside High Court, TBS. Email publications@ayindesanni.com or WhatsApp +2347056667384. Purchase Link: https://paystack.com/buy/evidence-act-complete-annotation

______________________________________________________________________ “Enhance Legal Practice With Authoritative Reports” — Alexander Payne Offers Comprehensive Law Reports, Spanning Over A Century Of Nigerian Jurisprudence

Interested buyers are encouraged to place their orders and enquiries via: 0704 444 4777, 0704 444 4999, 0818 199 9888 Website: www.alexandernigeria.com

______________________________________________________________________

“A Comprehensive Guide To Evidence Law” — Releases Second Edition In Three Volumes, Covering 4,051 Cases

  For enquiries and orders, contact: 08035526491 Email: jerryamadisilk@gmail.com Prof. Jerry Amadi’s Evidence Law, Second Edition (2026), contains 3,314 pages in three volumes, covering the Evidence Act 2011, its 2023 amendment, and 4,051 Nigerian and English cases.